McKinsey Senior Partner Carolyn Dewar reached a conclusion that reframes the entire CEO-effectiveness question: it is not what great CEOs do that sets them apart, but how they think. The behaviors are downstream of the mindsets. For PE-backed CEOs — who operate under compressed timelines, intense scrutiny, and an explicit value creation mandate — the distinction is not academic. It is the difference between a CEO who can execute a thesis at pace and one who can't.
Two bodies of McKinsey research speak directly to this: six mindsets that separate good CEOs from great ones, and ten ways PE CEOs in particular win. Read together, they describe a leader who thinks like an investor, builds like a system designer, and executes with the urgency the hold period demands.
ST · 01The six mindsets of great CEOs
How great CEOs think (McKinsey / Carolyn Dewar)
- Be bold — set a transformative vision that redefines the company's mission, not just incremental goals.
- Treat the soft stuff as the hard stuff — culture, talent, and leadership development are as critical as financials.
- Solve for team psychology — build a real leadership team with an enterprise-first mindset, not a set of siloed executives.
- Manage up strategically — leverage the board as a strategic partner, not a formality.
- Know when to engage — use a principled framework to decide when to speak out on external issues.
- Do what only you can do — focus on uniquely CEO-level tasks and delegate the rest.
The throughline is leverage of self. Great CEOs are ruthless about spending their attention only where it is uniquely theirs to spend — a theme that recurs across the PE-specific research as 'time is capital.' They treat culture and team psychology not as soft adjacencies but as the hard machinery that determines whether strategy survives contact with the organization.
ST · 02The ten ways PE CEOs win
How PE CEOs outperform (McKinsey)
PE CEOs outperform because they operate with intensity, discipline, and an investor mindset.
- Talent is the primary lever — build and continuously upgrade a leadership team that can execute the VCP now and at exit.
- Profit over growth — kill bad revenue — eliminate revenue that destroys margin rather than chasing top line.
- Operate with an investor lens — constantly evaluate the business like an investor to find gaps, risks, and upside.
- Clean-sheet the organization — redesign functions from the ground up for efficiency and performance.
- Governance as a value creation tool — use the board as an active partner driving alignment, speed, and better decisions.
- Time is capital — allocate time intentionally toward the highest-value activities.
- Operate under extreme pressure — deliver outsized results quickly despite constraints.
- Long-term mindset, short-term execution — build a durable business while executing with urgency.
- Culture is focused and pragmatic — shape culture around performance and accountability tied directly to the VCP.
- Leadership traits that matter — win through ambition, learning agility, self-awareness, and stakeholder management.
ST · 03Mindsets plus behaviors: the full framework
Taken together, the six mindsets and the ten behaviors form a coherent operating philosophy. The mindset 'do what only you can do' becomes the behavior 'time is capital.' The mindset 'treat the soft stuff as the hard stuff' becomes 'talent is the primary lever' and 'culture is focused and pragmatic.' The mindset 'manage up strategically' becomes 'governance as a value creation tool.' The thinking and the doing are the same discipline expressed at two levels.
ST · 04From traits to system
The trap is to read these as personality traits — qualities a CEO either has or lacks. The more useful reading is that they describe a system the CEO installs. 'Governance as a value creation tool' is a board cadence you design. 'Talent is the primary lever' is a deliberate leadership build. 'Clean-sheet the organization' is a structured redesign. These are not moods; they are mechanisms.
That is why outperformance is reproducible rather than purely innate. A CEO who installs the system — investor lens, talent priority, intentional time allocation, active governance, focused culture — operates like a top-quartile CEO even before becoming one. In an era where returns come from operating capability rather than financial conditions, the CEO who thinks and builds this way is the one who compounds the thesis.
ST · 05The investor lens as a daily practice
Of the ten behaviors, operating with an investor lens is the one that quietly organizes the rest. A CEO who constantly evaluates the business the way an outside investor would — hunting for gaps, pricing risks, identifying upside the organization has stopped noticing — naturally arrives at the other nine. The investor lens is what makes killing bad revenue obvious, what makes talent the priority, what makes time feel like the scarce capital it is. It is less a separate behavior than the operating posture that produces all of them.
This matters because it is learnable. A CEO doesn't have to be a former investor to adopt the lens; they have to install the habit of asking investor questions about their own business, regularly and without flinching. The CEOs who outperform are the ones who never stop underwriting their own company — treating every quarter as a fresh diligence rather than a status update.
ST · 06Time as the truly scarce capital
The behavior most often underrated is treating time as capital. A PE CEO operates under a compressed clock, yet many spend their attention as if it were abundant — absorbed into operational detail that a capable team should own. The great ones are ruthless about concentrating their time on the few activities that are uniquely theirs and that move enterprise value, and delegating everything else. This is the 'do what only you can do' mindset expressed as a calendar.
The discipline compounds. Time spent on the wrong things isn't just wasted — it is unavailable for the right things, in a hold period where there is no slack to recover it. The CEOs who treat their own attention as the portfolio's scarcest asset, and allocate it with the same rigor they'd apply to capital, are the ones who consistently execute the thesis at the pace the hold demands.
ST · 07Talent as the lever beneath every other behavior
If the investor lens is the posture that produces the ten behaviors, talent is the lever that makes them executable. McKinsey places it first among the ways PE CEOs win for a reason: a CEO can hold the sharpest investor lens in the industry, but without a leadership team capable of executing the VCP now and at exit, the insight produces nothing. The great PE CEOs build and continuously upgrade that team, treating leadership composition as the single highest-leverage decision they make.
This is also where the 'treat the soft stuff as the hard stuff' mindset becomes concrete. Building a real leadership team — one with an enterprise-first mindset rather than a set of siloed executives optimizing their own functions — is not a cultural nicety. It is the precondition for the systems thinking that lets a thesis survive contact with the organization. The CEOs who treat team-building as the hard, central work of the job are the ones whose strategies actually get executed; the ones who treat it as a soft adjacency watch good strategies dissolve into functional turf.
ST · 08Governance as a tool the CEO wields
The behavior most foreign to leaders coming from outside private equity is using governance as a value creation tool. In many corporate settings, the board is something a CEO manages around — an oversight body to be satisfied. The outperforming PE CEO inverts this, treating the board as an active partner that drives alignment, speed, and better decisions. 'Manage up strategically,' in the mindset framing, becomes a board cadence the CEO deliberately designs to extract strategic thought partnership rather than mere oversight.
This matters all the more given how often the CEO-board relationship underdelivers. Research shows fewer than a quarter of CEOs feel they receive effective board support, even as directors believe they're providing it — and effective board support correlates with higher shareholder return and better goal achievement. The PE CEO who actively designs the governance relationship, rather than passively enduring it, converts a common source of friction into a genuine value creation lever. Like every other behavior on McKinsey's list, it is not a trait the CEO is born with. It is a system the CEO installs — and the installation is what turns these behaviors from a description of great CEOs into a reproducible way of operating like one.
Frequently asked
What is McKinsey's core finding about great CEOs?
That what separates great CEOs isn't what they do but how they think. McKinsey's Carolyn Dewar identified six mindsets — be bold, treat the soft stuff as the hard stuff, solve for team psychology, manage up strategically, know when to engage, and do what only you can do — that drive the behaviors of the most effective leaders.
How do PE CEOs outperform specifically?
Through ten behaviors McKinsey identifies: making talent the primary lever, killing bad revenue, operating with an investor lens, clean-sheeting the organization, using governance as a value tool, treating time as capital, performing under pressure, pairing long-term mindset with short-term execution, building focused culture, and demonstrating learning agility and self-awareness.
Are these CEO traits innate or learnable?
Largely learnable, because they describe a system a CEO installs rather than fixed personality traits. Active governance is a board cadence you design, talent leverage is a deliberate leadership build, and clean-sheeting is a structured redesign — mechanisms that can be adopted, not moods one is born with.
Why does the investor mindset matter for PE CEOs?
Because in an operational era, returns come from making the business genuinely better rather than from financial conditions. A CEO who constantly evaluates the company like an investor — finding gaps, risks, and upside — keeps the organization focused on the few moves that move enterprise value at exit.
Great PE CEOs install systems, not heroics.
Sync-Align is the operating system behind the behaviors that define outperforming PE CEOs — talent as the primary lever, governance as a value tool, and time treated as capital.
Operate like a top-quartile CEO →